Was Freud Wrong?

By: Shannon Chang

I didn’t shower this morning.  Nor yesterday.  And according to Freud, that is what I’m naturally inclined to do – bask in my slovenly glory.  Apparently I don’t like being on time either or, for that matter, any other social restriction civilization imposes on me.  I guess that means the less structure I have the better.  But frankly, I find that hard to believe.  I’m not working this semester.  And it was fun at first – getting up late, hanging out, getting to do the things I wanted, but it’s fast losing the luster of novelty.  I’m getting bored.  And for Fromm, that can only lead to bad things because if someone doesn’t have the sense of a productive life, he runs the risk of becoming violent.  Even worse, he’d be violent just for the pleasure of it.  So, maybe Freud was wrong, or at least partially so – we don’t like the way civilization dictates our lives, but we certainly need it to avoid devolving into a mass of reckless beasts.

Leave a Reply